We live in a secularized atmosphere, where “reality” means the hard stuff around us, but generally does not include what we believe religiously. We live in the neutral zone – the first floor of the universe where only a suspension of the natural law will yield contact with God. This, by no means, is the dogma of the Church. Instead, it is the legacy of the history of the late years of Western Civilization, a by-product of the Reformation and the popular response to its ideas. It is, or will be, the death of Christianity as taught by Christ unless it is resisted and renounced. from Careful Devotion to Christ
Over the past years of my Christian walk, one realization has been placed in stark relief — if Christians only loved one another, then we would be unable to build churches fast enough. Every person in the world is born with a need for Love and Love’s call is too often drowned out by the things of the world. This is true of the just and unjust alike, and our secular Western societies have produced far too many loveless Christians.
One simple example is the homeless or those purporting to be homeless. Too many times I have heard Christians label those begging at street corners as “scammers.” Frankly, I would rather be scammed by nine fake homeless so that the one truly homeless person receives my help. Although an example of not loving the unjust, there are far too many examples of Christians not loving their own. Much of it has to do with the influences of said secular society. Football, golf, hunting, gossiping with the girls about their husbands, society demanding that husbands “earn” respect instead of giving it freely, while simultaneously expecting a husband to provide love without question, and the list goes on and on.
Although much blame can be laid at the feet of believers, the pastorate has lost focus too often as well. How many churches have a weekly “altar call”? How does an altar call relate to the undershepherd (pastor) empowering the sheep for their dual mission of loving God and loving others? It doesn’t. Altar calls are primarily directed at the lost who, if they’re in church to begin with, should be evangelized by the ones who brought him or her or a member of the diaconate or simply a church member, but certainly not the pastor from the pulpit.
Yet, there is another area that pastors lead sheep astray, and that is their theological bent.
The Western Christian tradition has been reduced to a constant battle of whose system of theology and the resulting “interpretation” of Scripture is correct. From the unjust person’s perspective, how does this glorify God? How is it demonstrative of Christians’ love “one for another”? How does it point to the message of the one True God? How is it any different than idolizing the Dallas Cowboys?
Thus, we must ask whether there is such a thing as Theologic Pantheism. Additionally, we ask if we can we accurately apply the pantheistic label to advocates advancing different systems of theology and, if so, what are the criteria?
If we accept that all of God’s creation is good and that man defiled God’s creation with his sin, then we begin laying a foundation for exploring the question. From a Christian perspective, God loves perfectly, God is love, He saved us because He loves us, He loves us first, God plays no favorites (He makes the sun to shine and the rain to fall on the just and unjust). Furthermore, we come to understand God’s deep love the more we humble ourselves, die to self, and serve Him by allowing His love to flow through us to others. And because the Lord Love is relational, He wants us to receive His love, return His love, and then allow His love to flow through us to others.
Of course, this last element of God’s love can be lost rather quickly in a competitive Western world that screams that “self” is the most important thing in the universe. It’s really no wonder Muslims see Western Christians as infidels, because most of the time the majority of Western Christendom is acting like infidels — even by the standards of our Scriptures.
With the competing systems of Western theology come some pretty interesting interpretations. Everything from the hyper-Calvinist view that evangelizing is unnecessary because God pre-destines everyone for Heaven or Hell to the universalist view that God loves us so much He will let no one perish, regardless of their behavior or belief. In defense of these positions, and the advancing of a plethora of systems in between, men and women confessing Christ invest incredible amounts of time defending their pet views of the Great Commission, eschatology, baptism (paedo or believer’s), etc.
So how does this investment of time further the Kingdom of God? It doesn’t. And, having been privy to many different systematic theology discussions, I find the tone of them to be rather strident and unloving. Again, how does an unloving conversation further the Kingdom of God? It doesn’t.
Why the time and investment and conversations fail to achieve the very thing the participants think they are doing is simple — they are not focused on God.
To be sure, they think they are focused on God, but let’s look at a stark reality: God didn’t tell us to create any system of theology, but God did give us a liturgy to follow, and the first Christians followed the liturgy during Synagogue worship. Granted, we need to have a framework that allows finite man to vaguely understand an Infinite God, but too often the Holy Spirit’s role is discounted by theologians. Moreover, if we look at specific tenets of some systems and ask how they reflect Christ’s command to love God and love others, we walk away unable to answer the question. And if we cannot answer the question, than the tenet is not of God but of man and, therefore, the tenet’s adherents are engaging in worship of the created instead of the Creator.
Yes, we can probably devolve into a discussion of whether this is pantheism or idolatry. It really doesn’t matter which label we use. What matters is the lack of focus on Love and Mercy identified here, and those examples that readily come to mind in the reader. Thus, when we fail to love, we sin. It’s that simple. For the Lord is Love and He wants tender love-filled hearts in His bond servants. Servants who have the status of adopted children and who’ve been invited to participate with Him in loving one another and reaching the lost.
A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another. John 13:34